Ellen Macarthur Foundation

 

Chapter IV - Just a revamped "use less and recycle" approach?

Taking the problem at its root – the design of products – is a totally different way of thinking, say McDonough and Braungart who point out that, while it’s a laudable effort, to simply use less and recycle is not a valid solution, it only amounts to being “less bad”, by reducing the activity of the metabolism but not changing it at all.

New_factbox_3c477661c57637bc837bfb983d06b68b02efa13a.jpg

To reduce emissions, or to dilute them, as the authors put it, is merely a lesser evil: “This solution to pollution – dilution – is an outdated and ineffective response that does not examine the design that caused the pollution in the first place”

In a nutshell, “less bad” is where we end up by not changing the model but improving our behaviour through recycling and other comparable initiatives. Thinking that waste reduction and energy conservation measures alone will be sufficient to guarantee us a brighter future is an illusion, and as McDonough and Braungart write somewhat bluntly:

Relying on eco-efficiency to save the environment will in fact achieve the opposite; it will let industry finish off everything, quietly, persistently, and completely.

By the same token, Cradle to Cradle prefers to talk about “downcycling” rather than “recycling” since in the system as we know it, materials are reused in lesser objects before ultimately becoming waste.

Read further: Chapter V – In Reality, how does that translate ?

Download as PDF

News

New circularity assessment tools laun...
12th May 2015 – The Ellen MacArthur Foundation and Granta Design have launched new indicators which, fo...
Latest insight and circular economy n...
24th April 2015 – Circulate, the Ellen MacArthur Foundation's new hub for circular economy news, editoria...
Top speakers confirmed for Re-thinkin...
26th February 2015 – We are pleased to reveal the latest list of confirmed speakers and sessions for our ann...
Ellen MacArthur joins the TED2015 lin...
23rd February 2015 – We are thrilled to announce that Ellen MacArthur will join the line up of speakers at T...

The Economics

The first macroeconomic report series into the size of the prize for business in the transition to a circular economy

Book

Sign up for updates

Register to receive a monthly update from the Foundation, with latest news, editorial comment and event opportunities

Resource downloads

Film clips, publications, colour graphics, presentations…raw material for a range of educational activities.

Resources

Global Partners of the Ellen MacArthur Foundation


Circular Economy 100 Members