Publicado em
EmpresasModa

Junte-se a Seb enquanto ele conversa com a CEO da Fundação Ellen MacArthur, Jonquil Hackenberg, sobre os desafios e oportunidades que estão por vir para a economia circular em 2026.

Quais são suas prioridades para 2026? Conte pra gente nos comentários ou na nossa página do LinkedIn.

Transcript

Alice Marshall [00:00] So I think what this policy will also do is encourage more players to enter, which maybe sounds a bit counterintuitive, but I think more competition that there is, the better the industry becomes.

Seb Egerton-Read [00:15] Hello and welcome to The Circular Economy Show. Earlier this year, a group of fashion businesses signed a statement saying that certain policy interventions are needed to level the playing field and incentivize the right kind of behaviors amongst businesses to bring circular economy to life in the industry. Our host Pippa caught up with Alice from Zalando and Hortense from Vestiaire Collective to find out why they did it and what they hope happens next.

Pippa Shawley [00:45] So welcome both. Hortense, if we can come to you first. We talk about circular business models and Vestiaire Collective was sort of founded with that in mind. So what does circular business models look like at your organization?

Hortense Pruvost [00:57] Circular business models hold a core environmental mission. They exist to break the link between economic growth and resource extraction by keeping existing garments in use for as long as possible and progressively reducing the pressure to produce new. So that's very much the reason Vestiaire Collective was created a few years ago. Vestiaire Collective is the leading global platform for premium secondhand fashion. We provide curation, logistics, and authentication to facilitate transactions between individuals mostly, but we also have a few alternative models. We have professional sellers, some VIPs, and a brand partnership model that we'll talk a bit about. Just to step back on the environmental mission for a circular business model and to give a bit order of magnitude, if we are to align the fashion industry with a 1.5-degree Paris Agreement trajectory, CBMs might reach a 23% market share by 2030 because they hold so much of the capacity to deliver the required emission cuts. For the industry. But right now, again, to give you a perspective of where we are, even in best scenarios, the current market penetration of secondhand is only at 8 to 10%. And meanwhile, of course, we have— we've had succeeding waves of ultra-fast and then ultra-fast fashion flooding the market. So the sense of urgency for scaling circular business models is even Even higher.

Pippa Shawley [02:25] And Alice, tell me about Zalando, because that's a slightly different type of business to Vestiaire. This is a development of your business?

Alice Marshall [02:33] Yes, very much so. So the core of Zalando's business is still in the firsthand linear model. But we have what the part of the business that I run, which is recommerce, where we have kind of 2 halves of the proposition. One half where we buy back items from customers that they purchased on Zalando, and the other half where we actually sell those customers Sorry, sell those items to other customers. And that's— we really came at that from the point of view, of course, knowing that circular business models, as Hortense mentioned, are super important in terms of reducing the overall impact of the fashion industry on the environment. However, we also came at this from the angle of how can we solve a problem for our customers? And we know that many Zalando customers, customers in general, people in general, are very interested in not only clearing out their wardrobe and passing on items that they no longer wear, wear, maybe no longer fit, so they can be used by somebody else and maybe making some— gaining some value from that, some money from that. And also for customers who are wanting to start buying secondhand, maybe dip their toe in the water, maybe they're not so confident to use a C2C site because they want the trust and the convenience that they expect from shopping on a platform like Zalando. So we really came at the angle of trying to solve both of those customer problems, and that's how our proposition is set up. So we offer our customers the opportunity to trade in with us. We take the items that they send to us and process them ourselves in a facility in Poland. We check the quality and we then put those live on site for our customers to buy.

Pippa Shawley [04:16] And that sounds great. What have you seen since you've introduced that? What's gone well for Zalando in that respect?

Alice Marshall [04:23] So we've seen a huge amount of demand for secondhand fashion, for the buying part. So when we take an item from a customer and put it online, we find that on average those items sell out within the first 7 days of being listed. And for some brands that are a little bit more premium, they sell out within 24 hours. So we can see we've got really quite a significant demand from our customers for this. Where we actually have a bit more of a challenge is in supply. So we know that customers come to Zalando generally to shop. That's sort of what's in their mind when they visit Zalando. So we're really working on how can we change that mindset in our customers and help them understand that we offer this amazing service where they can also sell back to us. And they can do that in a very risk-free way. They don't have to pay for the shipping of the items. We do all the processing. It's all completely trustworthy and convenient. And they don't have to deal with another customer, which I know can be sometimes something that's quite fun for people in the B2C environment where they enjoy maybe negotiating and building a community. But we also know that some customers who just don't want to have to do that, they want just the sort of convenience of sending stuff off and knowing it's going to be used by someone and not sent to landfill, and they're happy with that. So that's where we're really trying to encourage more and more customers to experience and use this service because we believe it's a really great solution.

Pippa Shawley [05:57] So making it as frictionless as possible, whereas Vestiaire Hortense, I guess, is for the more entrepreneurial-spirited. So what's success looked like so far for you?

Hortense Pruvost [06:07] So Vestiaire Collective exists for more than 15 years, and I think the years of hypergrowth are behind us. There was this wave, I would say COVID and post-COVID was really a huge wave for e-commerce in general, and thankfully the secondhand market profited of that too. So it was a moment also of rapid democratization of the secondhand reflex, like Alice was saying. I think now it's in most consumer minds that you can shop secondhand. And I think now for the past 2, 3 years, we've reached a bit the age of maturity. So we're looking to reach profitability, which means that we have slowed down a bit on growth. And also, I think that's everything that you were saying about customer demands is also why we're looking to develop brand partnerships. And we've developed one with with Zalando, and I think that's why it makes so much sense, is that we actually have tons of supply and a lot of very faithful clients that are really used to put their items online. So for us, enlarging demand is super interesting, and especially enlarging demand for consumers that might not have, you know, the reflex yet to go to Vestiaire and might shop other types of fashion. And yes, in the past years, we've also invested quite a lot of time and resources to demonstrate the benefits of secondhand. So we've managed to show with comparative LCS that the service that we provide, so buying pre-loved on Vestiaire Collective versus buying a firsthand item in a shop, reduces the environmental impact. So carbon, water, waste, if you monetize all of this, you're able to Yes, to put them end-to-end. And it's a reduction of 90% of the environmental cost compared to buying new. And we also look into a lot of consumer effects, of course, the substitution effect and the different rebound effects. So I think that's also part of what we've achieved in the past years. We now have a clearer view of the magnitude of the environmental service that circular business provides.

Pippa Shawley [08:22] And you also had the quite unique experience of appearing on Emily in Paris as well as a brand. Yes. I'm sure had a real impact on bringing it to new audiences.

Hortense Pruvost [08:33] Yes, exactly. I think really the challenge of the consumer challenge is always culture, right? You need to enter pop and regular culture, and Emily in Paris was a very positive sign in this.

Pippa Shawley [08:47] And a very positive thing as well. And for both of you, it sounds like you've put a lot of— both your organizations have put a lot of effort into getting it to this point. I wonder what's holding you back, because the reason we're talking today is that the Ellen MacArthur Foundation is releasing a business statement about why we need policy levers to scale circular business models for fashion. And I wonder what that looks like for you in your day-to-day operations. So maybe Alice, if we come to you first on that.

Alice Marshall [09:15] Yeah, so I think the challenge for us with resale at Zalando is that in some ways being part of a bigger business is a bonus because it means that we have all of the logistics and operational power of Zalando behind us. But of course, being part of a publicly listed large business like Zalando, we also need to make sure that our proposition is financially viable, to make sure it's sustainable from both senses of the word, that we can sustain that business in not lose money, as well as the sustainability side of the impact. And so the policy that will really help us is around the VAT reduction. So, I mean, we already benefit from marginal VAT, which helps us in some ways in terms of making our business financially viable. However, matching the VAT to a new item, of course, is challenging. I mean, the economics of Handling single-item orders, single-item SKUs is anyway extremely challenging. We offer free delivery and free returns like we do with all of our assortment, and we process all of those items in our warehouse, as I said. And I think anyone that's working in the pre-owned space knows, if it's not C2C anyway, that there's a huge amount of human element that comes into dealing with a high number of single-item single SKU items. And so we've got to a place where we are financially viable, but if we had a little bit more room in our margin, we would use that to really feed back into our customer experience. So that's about making it just even more smooth for the customer to shop secondhand as it is for firsthand, so that we're encouraging more people to do it. I mean, that's our ultimate aim here and the aim, of course, of the policy. So we would reinvest that margin into improved shopping experience, improved inspiration for the customer. We would just have a little bit more wriggle room to invest margins so that the pricing is really attractive for the customer and to make sure that the convenience element is as attractive as it is on our first-hand assortment.

Pippa Shawley [11:31] Thank you. And Hortense, what about you?

Hortense Pruvost [11:33] I think there's 2 things, and responding a bit to what you were— aligning with what you were saying, Alice, there's 2 different things. There's the policy bit. So policy-wise, For me, I think policies are really a step behind because we've now invested the resources to prove these amazing environmental benefits that I was talking about and concrete contribution to the ecological transition of this resale model, especially this resale model that doesn't go through an industrial process again, not like recycling. So it's even— it's really the at-scale business model that we have at hand to contribute to the transition. But it's like And yet public policies right now are agnostic, if not sometimes a bit punitive for this business model, that it's still hit by double taxation and high domestic labor. Because also, again, like if we go back to what is our main competitor, what I believe is our main competitor right now, which is still fast and ultra-fast fashion that people are buying massively, there's a price incentive. And of course, we can talk about this, but there's also the capacity that this linear mass production model has to achieve mass economies of scale that exactly like Alice was saying, we don't have in the recommerce resale sector because we deal with the units. So there's of course higher tax labor, higher costs and lower margins with this model. And also we operate with a lot of different local models, so we don't offshore also labor the way that we operate is that we have a logistics center per continent where we're active in for authentication and quality control. Not all items go through physical authentication process, but to be able to provide trust in the luxury market above a certain range, we do automatize the fact that it goes through physical authentication. So all of this comes at a cost. Truly believe it's the business model that provides enough trust for these online transactions. But it does mean that also a green signal from public policies would be super helpful to compete. And the price signal, I think, is super important and interesting to discuss too. If we take the parallel with the— I love taking this parallel with the automobile industry, for example, that has a 50/50 balance between secondhand and firsthand now, occasion and firsthand cars. Well, the price incentive to buy a secondhand car right now is enormous because it's on average half the price. And we don't really have this again, especially in the past couple of years with the explosion of ultra-fast fashion. Price signal is a bit all over the place in the fashion industry, and you don't really have this big price incentive to go for secondhand. Not necessarily. It depends what kind of items you shop. So anything, and for sure it would be also our first reinvestment, would be on the price signal to reduce reduce our commission to be more competitive and to make the service as accessible as possible to as many consumer profiles.

Pippa Shawley [14:47] That's such a great comparison because I think for most of us, it's a no-brainer that you would go for a secondhand car over a brand new one unless there were certain things in place that meant you did that. But maybe when you're buying secondhand clothing or pre-loved clothing, you want to see a price difference to make it worth buying. the secondhand over the original one. Before we wrap up, I'm just going to reiterate what that business statement is asking for, because you've mentioned a lot of it already, but it's reduced VAT across the EU and eliminated sales tax in Canada and the US on resale products and repair services. So you both talked about what that would do for your companies. The reduced labor taxes across the EU and an incentive package that includes labor tax credits in Canada and the US. for jobs involved in resale and repair operations, which again you've also talked about a lot. And also extended producer responsibility or EPR policy to help create separate collection and sorting infrastructure at scale. And Hortense, you've touched on there what the business statement might do for Vestiaire, but what would it being realized really mean for the organization and your work?

Hortense Pruvost [16:00] So first, I think it would be a huge sign of public recognition and support. And, you know, coming from a, from policymakers showing that they have confidence that we are building a business model that is good, that is solid and sustainable, and that needs to become this consequent share of the industry like we were discussing. Then, of course, the price signal. I talked a bit about this. Another reinvestment that we could make with higher margin, because everything that the statement we do is higher margin for us, is marketing. Again, like if we compare ourselves too big for sand brands. Our marketing budgets are really low, but marketing is also how you get more customer adoption. So making the service and the model known. And then there's also all of this product side that is super important for us, making the service as fluid and seamless as possible. We have AI coming in. We've already released our new AI-powered listing form, but there's a lot of innovation and rapid uptake that we need to do in the next years to make the discovery and the personalization experience as seamless as possible and as attractive, if not more attractive, than the firsthand experience. And all of this will be a virtuous cycle because every time we hit people growth, for us growth is also— sorry, how do I say that? Ah, I'm going to say it differently. It translates directly into any growth, translates directly into recruitments in our operations, because as you were saying, it's a per-item model. So anytime we have more items coming through our hubs, it means that we have more people for quality control and authentication. And all of this is further facilitated by lower labor costs as proposed by the policy statement. So really, it would be a great virtuous circle for resale.

Pippa Shawley [17:59] Love the sound of a virtuous circle. Alice, is there anything else you want to add today about the future of circular business models within Zalando?

Alice Marshall [18:08] Yeah, and maybe I just, before I talk about that, I also want to just pick up on something that Hortense mentioned just then around the impact that the policy would have. I think more broadly as well, like this is, as you said earlier, Hortense, like this is definitely the fastest growing part of the fashion industry at the moment. However, it's still not growing as quickly as we need it to in order to get to the goals for the climate. So I think what this policy will also do is encourage more players to enter, which maybe sounds a bit counterintuitive, but I think more competition that there is, the better the industry becomes and the more customers will, you know, convert to buying secondhand. Yes. Also, what we're seeing at the moment is many, many startups entering the space, and I think the more encouragement and space they have to grow from a financial point of view, the more innovation, the more AI will be adopted to help us all grow eventually. That feels really exciting to me. And then in terms of where we're going specifically at Zalando, I mean, I mentioned earlier that our biggest challenge to growth is really supply and changing the customer mindset to sell with us as well as buy from us. And a short-term solution that we've been playing with is to actually get supply from elsewhere, not just from our customers. So that's actually what led us to partnering with Vestiaire Collective. This year because we wanted to see, A, can we just get more supply for our customers? And B, will they be interested in buying on Zalando Vestiaire Collective's authenticated luxury and designer fashion secondhand? And that's been really successful. We see there's a very high level of customer demand, and that gives us confidence to know that that's an area we can explore even more with Vestiaire Collective, of course, but also with other partnerships, not just in the luxury space, but generally in the space of Are there other partners out there who have secondhand stock that they want to have more customers see, to reach the huge customer reach that we have at Zalando, that we can open that up beyond just our own supply? And I think that's really exciting because again, it brings us into this virtuous cycle that Hortense was talking about, that the more customers are exposed to this, the more they switch the mindset to thinking secondhand before firsthand. then the more impact we can have jointly.

Pippa Shawley [20:33] So the business signals are there that this is working.

Alice Marshall [20:36] Absolutely.

Pippa Shawley [20:37] We need those policy levers to help level the playing field and encourage more circular activity. And then also, it sounds like collaboration is what's really going to put the fire underneath this kind of business. I'm really excited to see what happens over the next couple of years because It does, it feels like a moment of change. And I think you're both important players in that. So thank you so much for sharing your stories today and joining us on The Circular Economy Show.

Seb Egerton-Read [21:09] It really is a truism to say that shifting the system requires action from businesses, from policy, from NGOs, from startups and innovators, all types of actors. But often the question is, well, what does that really look like? And I think what we heard in that conversation is a really tangible action to try and shift that system forward. That was also the last episode hosted by the wonderful Pippa Shawley. Pippa has been with us for 6 years. She's hosted more than 50 episodes of this podcast and been part of producing many, many more. She's very important to everything we've done on the Circular Economy Show. And I just want to say, thank you, Pippa, for all your work. And we wish you all the with what's next. We'll put some links in the show notes so that if you want to connect with Pippa and find out what she's doing next, you can do. Other than that, thank you so much for listening to another episode of the Circular Economy Show. Do subscribe to us, give us a like, give us a review, share with colleagues, and we'll see you on the next episode.

Você também pode gostar

  • Empresas
  • Moda